Versus · Luxury Outdoor Grills
Alfresco ALXE‑42VSAmerican Muscle Grill...
✓
For most buyers, the Alfresco ALXE‑42 wins. Alfresco ALXE‑42 edges ahead of American Muscle Grill AMG36 for most buyers, especially when gas (pellet for wood flavour) matters most. However, American Muscle Grill AMG36 is the stronger pick if you prioritize gas (pellet for wood flavour). Each scoring rule ties your quiz answers to product attributes.
✨ Searching for deals...
Updated Apr 9, 20265+ dimensionsNo sponsored rankingsPrices checked today
Alfresco ALXE‑42
Alfresco ALXE‑42
See on Amazon →
Alfresco ALXE‑42
Winner
vs
American Muscle Grill...
American Muscle Grill...
$13,270
See on Amazon →
American Muscle Grill... · $13,270
⚡
Personalize this comparison
Tell us your priorities and we'll re-score both products for YOU
▾
Luxury Outdoor Grills / Versus
Alfresco ALXE‑42 is no longer available
Looking for an alternative to compare with American Muscle Grill AMG36? Here are some similar options, or take our quiz for a personalized recommendation.
Top pick
Alfresco ALXE‑42
Match score50%
Gas (pellet for wood flavour)Freestanding cart (pick freestanding for mobility)Small
vs
American Muscle Grill AMG36
by American Muscle Grill
Check today’s price →
Match score50%
Gas (pellet for wood flavour)Freestanding cart (pick freestanding for mobility)Large
Check today’s price →
Alfresco ALXE‑42FeatureAmerican Muscle Grill AMG36
Alfresco
Brand
American Muscle Grill
Gas (natural gas or propane)
Fuel type
Hybrid / Multi‑fuel
Medium (600–800 sq in)
Much cooking capacity
Large (≥ 800 sq in)
Rotisserie and smoker capabilities
Special feature
Hybrid multi‑fuel flexibility
Three 27,500 BTU stainless burners with ceramic…
Standout
Hybrid design accepts gas, charcoal, wood or…

Still deciding?

These are just 2 of 31+ products we evaluate in Luxury Outdoor Grills. Take our 60-second quiz to get a personalized recommendation across all of them.

Take the full quiz

Key differences: Alfresco ALXE‑42 vs American Muscle Grill AMG36

Choosing between the Alfresco ALXE‑42 and the American Muscle Grill AMG36 comes down to what matters most to you in a luxury outdoor grills. Fuel type has the biggest impact on flavour and ease of use.

The Alfresco ALXE‑42 leans toward gas, while the American Muscle Grill AMG36 offers hybrid / multi‑fuel. Cooking capacity is measured in square inches of primary grilling area. The Alfresco ALXE‑42 leans toward medium, while the American Muscle Grill AMG36 offers large.

Luxury grills offer features beyond basic grilling. The Alfresco ALXE‑42 leans toward rotisserie and smoker capabilities, while the American Muscle Grill AMG36 offers hybrid multi‑fuel flexibility.

The Alfresco ALXE‑42 stands out for users who value gas (pellet for wood flavour) and freestanding cart (pick freestanding for mobility) and small.

Meanwhile, the American Muscle Grill AMG36 is the stronger pick if gas (pellet for wood flavour) and freestanding cart (pick freestanding for mobility) and large are your top priorities.

Rather than declaring an absolute winner, we recommend using the interactive comparison above — your priorities determine which product scores higher.

Also compare

Alfresco ALXE‑42 vs Big Green EggAlfresco ALXE‑42 vs Camp ChefAlfresco ALXE‑42 vs DCS Series 9 Evolution 36-InchAlfresco ALXE‑42 vs Kamado Joe

Best Luxury Outdoor Grills guides